I think this may be my new favorite EK book although I will always be absolutely obsessed with The Score (Allie & Dean 😍) and I always rate her books 5 stars but this one deserves more than a 5 for me. It was total perfection and just so much more than I expected. My expectations were super high too but it was just too good! Shane and Diana were everything, their banter was hilarious, they have a whole frenemies thing going on and then you also get fake dating, close proximity, and sports. This had so much depth, it made me swoon so hard, it cracked me up and I wasn’t expecting to be a sobbing mess but I was?! Can we talk about how hot this one was too pls? Good lord Shane and Diana were insane together, there was one particular spicy scene that had my jaw on the floor and the kink was unexpected and 🥵 I think my jaw was on the floor more than it ever has been while reading a romance, so many surprises and so many emotions, I loved every single page of this perfect book!!