I liked this one! It's a why choose about a girl named Harper whose awful boyfriend blindsides her and his teammates when he leaves with his other girlfriend to play for a different college team. His three teammates he lived with begrudgingly let her stay while she tries to find somewhere to live since she was supposed to move into a new place with the jerk the next day. The three, Silas, Carter, and Dylan, don't really like her but they all soon learn that they don't know the real her, and once they do it's electric between them all. She ends up with all three of them, then they decide to share and she's dating them all. Because of their actions (accidental but still their fault) she ends up getting hurt and it causes issues for a while until they all work it out. I liked that she became best friends with Carter's twin sister Casey, and am hoping Casey gets her own book with Harper's brothers but I'm not sure she will since it wouldn't fit in the "ex" theme of this series.