Fully half of these stories were 5/5, which...never fuckin happens, man. 

I read this aloud to my 14y/o (as soon as I heard there was a Weird/Horror NMH inspired anthology, I told them about it and they said "welp, that's what we're reading next!"), and they made me highlight something in almost every story. 

Our lowest rating was 4/5, the average was 4.77. Might come back to bump this up to 5.