pn_hinton's profile picture

pn_hinton 's review for:

New Kid by Jerry Craft
3.0

I have to admit I was expecting more from this book and I think that is because I erroneously thought it was a memoir of sorts. Once I realized it wasn't and read with that mindset it helped a bit. It was cute while bringing up important topics in the Black community such as the idea of light skinned versus dark, the term "Oreo" and what it means, as well as constantly feeling that you have to prove yourself to both sides of the color line.

It even hinted at code-switching without calling it that just in Jordan's mannerisms and the way he carried himself. He felt like an outcast at his school and like one in his neighborhood because of his new school. It also touched on the reality that a lot of Black kids grow up hearing, which is that it's not enough to be as good you have to be better. Daddy Pope said and did a lot of terrible things on "Scandal" but on that he was spot on.

Since it was a graphic novel there were a lot of plot strings that were dangled but never fully pulled. So that was a bit disappointing even if I understood it. It would be nice to have a series and see things from other people's point of views but it serves well as a standalone.

One thing I did not like was Ms. Rawle. I don't think either Drew or Jordan ever told their parents about her. She was a walking stereotype all around between calling the kids by the different names because apparently she's terrible at her job and only saw color. Not to mention she carried over her bad experience with Deandre and took it out on Drew. I understand that was the purpose behind her but sadly there are teachers like that in the world and they're still allowed around children because we have a teacher shortage and it enrages me so much.

Overall a cute short read. I think it can lead to great discussions between parents and their kids, even if you can't pull a lot of actual context from the story and have to rely on other sources. But it is a good jumping off point.