verlorenimbuecherregal's profile picture

verlorenimbuecherregal 's review for:

The Long Refrain by Maya Jean
3.0
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

For short: As an ending to the series it's beautiful. The story on its own unfortunately has flaws especially in the mental health rep.

I kinda feel bad leaving a review including criticism, because Maya is a lovely human being, I adored especially the first two books from this series and I'm looking forward to everything that comes from her. And I also know that having something negative to say about a book so close to an author's heart can hurt, so I'm really hoping Maya doesn't read this - after all, reviews are for readers. Distorting the reviews with too positive reviews because the author struggles with criticism also makes it difficult for readers to know if a book is worth their time and sometimes money, so it just doesn't sit right with me and I decided to be "brutally" honest even tho I really really like Maya.

And I did love a lot about this book, beginning with the presence of the Sweet Southern found family who all have their own spot in my heart. Their support for Benji and Nolan was gorgeous and Harper and Nolan's friendship developing was really beautiful and I loved to witness that. Both Nolan and Benji as characters were lovable and while they had their flaws, they also were super sweet souls who just deserved finding their better half - and having a bit grumpy x sunshine but a bit differentiated also was really good. Also Nolan calling something romantic nice but boring is my vibe 😂 And I loved the "huge hockey player Grayson" as a link to JJ Mulder's universe, that's such a sweet homage. 

So the ground work or rather the ground plotting was solid, but it lacked in the execution. There were a lot of time jumps in the process of them getting to know each other and overall the book felt very rushed. They spent so much time together that wasn't shown on page, which would be fine if it then was told instead (even if show don't tell still is an important stylistic device), but it seemed like nothing changed in the dynamic between them even though they've spent SO much time together, they just stayed where they left off. So naturally there would have been at least some kind of development and as a reader that felt rather unnatural- so I didn't get a feeling for their dynamic. It's also not really clear why Benji is interested in Nolan at first - he gets to know Nolan only as super grumpy and pushing him away, and I guess Benji's heart is just made of gold and he has a kind of saviour complex, but we never see the spark igniting, Benji only ever talks about Nolan being interesting and worthy of love (which he definitely is, don't get me wrong, but I would have loved to see even a glimpse of vulnerability in the beginning.

The book is rather short with 238 pages for such a deep topic regarding mental health issues and unfortunately this is palpable - in not getting a grip on the characters' dynamic (the switch from Nolan being irritated with Benji to him liking Benji also was super sudden and it just didn't feel right) and also in not giving the mental health issues the space they needed. And that's my big problem with the book, because I think there are learnings regarding mental illness in there, that are quite dangerous to share them with people who might be affected by a mental illness. I do wanna say Benji's perspective as a loved one of a person with a mental illness was executed well - thinking you have to be strong all the time for the struggling person despite struggling yourself, and constantly being unbelievably scared the other person might hurt or unal!ve themselves. The only issue I've got here is that Benji doesn't talk about that with Nolan throughout the whole book - he only ever speaks to his best friend, which is valid for the beginning, but I think talking to your loved one about things that burden you and finding a way to work with that is key for establishing a healthy relationship. And I really struggled with the portrayal of mental illness beyond that.

Going on from here, there are some spoilers ahead, so be sure you want to read on please!

Nolan's illness and everything that's coming with it feels a bit too cliché. Benji's threat to jump with him if he jumps could have been straight out of some movie, Nolan having absolutely no problem with going to therapy and just accepts it, he's suddenly basically cured through seeing a therapist ONCE and having Benji - no human is the cure for a mental illness, people unal!ve themselves also in happy relationships and while they're in therapy, it is a super serious illness, and I think this book didn't give this seriousness justice. Also - someone who's just come back from their first therapy appointment, a very short time period after threatening to jump off a balcony and says he wants to take a nap alone, is no one I'd happily leave alone, but Benji doesn't even blink or check on him once, he just leaves the house for multiple hours. 
Nolan is fully functioning with one bad day in two months after starting therapy and taking meds and that's just not realistic. I know it is a romance and it doesn't have to be realistic, but I think portraying mental illnesses needs at least some realism. And Maya worked so much with time jumps throughout the beginning of the book, I don't know why she didn't use time jumps for Nolan's therapy journey. Chapter 14 for example starts with "So, therapy sucks" but it also happens in January 2028, the same month as the chapter before - here a time jump would have been so suiting? Nolan even talks about "how sick my brain was until that fateful day on the balcony" in the same chapter - like his brain was fixed by now, after not even a month in therapy. And I know his major trigger with being on tour was gone and that's super important for a healing journey, but removing a burnout trigger won't cure the burnout and also won't be leading to feeling super good instantly. It all takes time, and not just some months or even weeks, unfortunately. And what really made me a bit mad was Nolan asking Benji if he ever has bad days on a day Nolan couldn't leave the bed - and Benji answers with "You'll have good days and bad days. Life." and then giving advice how you go hiking or work out on your bad days to get out of the negative headspace just isn't something that's suiting if the person you're saying that to has been in therapy for a month and has a mental illness. Bad days coming with mental illnesses are just SO different than bad days mentally healthy people have. This almost smells like gaslighting and I actually think that's dangerous for mentally ill people who don't have a supporting network yet and reading this. I know that's harsh and I feel super bad because I know how heavily Maya takes criticism, so Maya, in case you've read this: I still love you and your writing and I will continue to read anything you wrote!

Also another minor point of criticism: Benji bottoming/them switching roles and Benji thinking they probably won't switch often in the future (so he obviously doesn't love it), but for now it's the closeness he craves and it feels important to have done that kinda feeds the image a lot of queer male reviewers often criticise when it comes to women or non-males writing MM - that image of penetration being needed and especially the other way around than they normally do it, to show how close they are or how deep their love is, and I think that's super dangerous. But I'm not a queer man, so I'd rather let them speak for themselves, it just rubbed me the wrong way.

Regarding the rushing, the HEA also felt suuuper fast. They arrived in Clay Springs in January 2028, Nolan started therapy and in March 2028 they hired constructors to build their home. It just felt super weird.

So all in all, I had my struggles with this book, but it's by far not a bad book. It being this rushed (and it also comes out barely three months after the previous book was released and Maya not continuing this series despite having planned one more book) despite the heavy topics might just be a hint that this also wasn't super easy to write and having it now finished, maybe another series or a standalone will give Maya the freedom to write what she wants again. 

So would I recommend it? If you've read and loved the rest of the series for sure (maybe even if you're like me and adored the first two books and had some struggles with the third), but don't read it as a standalone and don't start the series for this and have high expectations - still read the series tho because the first two books are among my favourite hurt/comfort books. And also please don't read it if you struggle with a mental illness and are not super stable. There are better mental illness rep books that show the ongoing fight better and still have a happy ending.