geoquartz's profile picture

geoquartz 's review for:

A Dance with Dragons by George R.R. Martin
4.5
adventurous challenging dark emotional mysterious tense slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

A Dance with Dragons, is a slow introspective for the character who survived the events of A Storm of Swords, similarly to a Feast for Crows which makes sense given that both books were meant as one. Unlike Feast, Dance follows the major three characters from A Song of Ice and Fire; Jon, Daenerys and Tyrion, along with the return of minor characters and introduction of new ones. As you can imagine Dance is filled to the brim (though only the second longest to A Storm of Swords.)

While regarded as the more boring of the ASOIAF books, I would disagree. Dance both acts as a reaction to the events of Storm, and a bridge to The Winds of Winter. There are countless schemes and plot riddled throughout the book, from the Wall in The North, down to the sands of Dorne. Many of which are left on cliff hangers. This being the cause of much resentment toward the book. Additionally Many of the characters go on great journeys: in the spiritual, personal and physical sense, to find themselves, their wants and their goals. No character of which ends of in the same place as they started it. 
The larger issues with the book are more of a result of Winds not being finished than it is of the book itself.

 As always the dense world of Ice and Fire never fails to fascinates me as George's prose never fails to wow me, but Dance does feel overstuffed at times. So many characters and plots leave us as readers wondering where any of this is going and if its going to be worth it. A questions readers have been pondering for 14 years. If Winds is completed I think Dance will be more highly regard as a leaping point for the conclusion of the series, though that would mean we need to wait for A Dream of Spring too, and who knows when that will be.