I love a witchy read, especially one that's full of mystery and has a dash of spice just like Sacrifice! 
I did like Alicia, though I did find her slightly annoying at times, the same with James (though we do like a bit of an ahole when it comes to book boyfriends, don't we?
The book did keep me guessing what the Hamilton's were hiding, and after that ending, I'm intrigued to see what happens next