Trying to figure out what I wanted to rate this book was hard. I enjoyed the characters, the plot, and the execution of how the story was told. I really loved how it went from present time told by Janie, then back in time to tell Annabelle’s and Bay’s story. The one thing I struggled with the book was the pacing. It had a lot of slow spots, which would make feel tired and want to put the book down. But, overall it was enjoyed and the ending was an omg moment.