Take a photo of a barcode or cover
geosbooks 's review for:
When Women Were Dragons
by Kelly Barnhill
challenging
emotional
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Okay I think a lot of people are going into this book with the wrong idea of what it is. It is not an action story, it is literary fiction, you will not get descriptions of dragons murdering people. That said I do think it’s very good and worth reading. Honestly I think the complaints about intersectionality are not super fair, the author is white and she stays in her lane about race and class and trans stuff but still mentions them, it’s just not the focus. Also most of the main women are dragons so who knows what race they are (although it’s probably white). (Also there’s so many lesbians in this). Think of it more as a coming of age/new adult book examining the complexities of patriarchy, queer identity and family.
My only critique is that the ending was very utopian. It wound up feeling a little too cheesy although no, it doesn’t all work out the way you’d dream. I don’t think there’s an issue with writing a better world than we live in, I actually think there’s something important in imagining how we can get to a world that is better than this so I didn’t mark anything down for it, it’s just a dramatic tone shift lol.
Come for the dragons stay for the analysis of what it is to grow and change as a family in a changing world.
My only critique is that the ending was very utopian. It wound up feeling a little too cheesy although no, it doesn’t all work out the way you’d dream. I don’t think there’s an issue with writing a better world than we live in, I actually think there’s something important in imagining how we can get to a world that is better than this so I didn’t mark anything down for it, it’s just a dramatic tone shift lol.
Come for the dragons stay for the analysis of what it is to grow and change as a family in a changing world.