this is so hard to rate. the first 75% was basically 5 stars. but i didnt like the time they spent apart; it was super weird!!! and idk the last quarter was just not it, esp the miscommunication, but i do think i prefer it to the last one. but i felt like ryan could have done a better job of communicating to her. like he really could have communicated what he wanted to say if he only tried harder. but i do love the characters and the story was quite beautiful.