Take a photo of a barcode or cover
mathildur 's review for:
Daughters of Sparta
by Claire Heywood
Edit: It is the morning after and I'm reading a different book that also explores the character of Helen, but in this book she has so much more personality already, and she's not even one of the main characters. The contrast to this became too stark to keep it at a 3, so I'm changing my rating to 2,5 stars.
If I had been more familiar with Helen and Klytemnestra's stories from before, this might have landed on a 2 star rating, but since it was fun to learn more about them it's raised to a 3. I am, however, quite disappointed with this retelling, mostly because both women were so incredibly passive. Klytemnestra's chapters I enjoyed throughout, but Helen never actually did anything?? I hated reading from her pov towards the end because she didn't even stop to consider any of the traumatic events that were happening around her in Troy, as it was sacked and all the people either slain or enslaved. It almost seemed like she didn't have a voice at all. I was also sad to see so many key elements from the Trojan war missing, such as Patroclus?? Achilles was just suddenly dragging Hektor's body away, but we never learnt that it was because he killed Patroclus. We never really experienced why the war shifted, nor did we get to witness Achilles' death. The Gods were also completely missing. Characters would pray and mention holy sites, but the actual influence of the Gods was nowhere to be seen. I feel like other than the new info I now have on Klytemnestra and Helen's domestic lives, this retelling didn't offer much new information or new insight.
Tldr: the book was fun enough, but so far from what I was expecting.
If I had been more familiar with Helen and Klytemnestra's stories from before, this might have landed on a 2 star rating, but since it was fun to learn more about them it's raised to a 3. I am, however, quite disappointed with this retelling, mostly because both women were so incredibly passive. Klytemnestra's chapters I enjoyed throughout, but Helen never actually did anything?? I hated reading from her pov towards the end because she didn't even stop to consider any of the traumatic events that were happening around her in Troy, as it was sacked and all the people either slain or enslaved. It almost seemed like she didn't have a voice at all. I was also sad to see so many key elements from the Trojan war missing, such as Patroclus?? Achilles was just suddenly dragging Hektor's body away, but we never learnt that it was because he killed Patroclus. We never really experienced why the war shifted, nor did we get to witness Achilles' death. The Gods were also completely missing. Characters would pray and mention holy sites, but the actual influence of the Gods was nowhere to be seen. I feel like other than the new info I now have on Klytemnestra and Helen's domestic lives, this retelling didn't offer much new information or new insight.
Tldr: the book was fun enough, but so far from what I was expecting.