You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

State of Wonder by Ann Patchett
3.0
adventurous challenging emotional mysterious reflective slow-paced

State of Wonder is about Marina, a pharmacologist who’s forced to travel to the Amazon in search of details about her colleague’s death—and get an update on the miracle fertility drug her company is financing. What she finds in the jungle is a conundrum that challenges her morals, future and sense of self.

I have so many conflicting feelings on finishing this.

On the one hand, it moved me to tears at parts and the writing was as immersive and engaging as I expected it to be after loving Tom Lake. But on the other hand, this was far too imperialistic for my taste; the characters felt a bit disconnected and out of reach; and the pacing was off (we went from languishing in slow, observational long chapters to a blitz of multiple huge events, reveals and entire journey home all in one finishing chapter). 

While morality and personal sacrifices for science does seem the central theme here, I just couldn’t get over the entitled and exploitative way the American doctors treated the indigenous people in this story, especially Easter, and then attempted to make us sympathetic to their callousness. Similarly, making her main character Marina half-Indian but choosing not to engage with that it any meaningful way beyond nightmares of her childhood visits to India felt like her race was being used as some kind of narrative crutch. None of it sat well, but perhaps that was the intention.

Patchett’s writing is top tier for me, so I fully enjoyed this buddy read despite my misgivings, and it definitely left me pondering some heavy questions I’m sure I’ll keep coming back to. Worth reading for sure.