The Book Club Hotel felt like a cozy Hallmark Christmas movie in book form — sweet characters, a festive setting, and predictable (but comforting) story-lines. I did enjoy the themes of change and growth, and

Erica’s

character had the most consistent and layered development. However, the book often told more than it showed, which made the emotional moments less impactful. The setting was cute, but I would have loved more vivid descriptions of the town and the people to truly bring it to life. The multiple POVs of each character also became a bit repetitive, and the quick, neat resolutions at the end felt rushed. Still, it was an easy, cozy read perfect for when you’re in the mood for something light and heartwarming! 🎄📚