abandonedquests's profile picture

abandonedquests 's review for:

2.0

I was excited for this collection of October horror shorts, but I think Kealan Patrick Burke's writing just doesn't work for me.

Dead Leaves was...fine, I guess? I read this with a group of horror lovers and folks were pretty mixed, some loved it, some felt very "meh" like me.

A lot of the stories are overwritten in a way that feels like Burke is trying for beautiful writing, but instead structures his sentences in a confusing way, or chooses words that don't quite fit.

I also found a lot of the stories felt like skeletons of stories, ideas without real characters or plots fully developed. Many of the stories felt quite vague.

There were a few that I liked. Someone to Carve the Pumpkins was lovely, short and sad in a good way. The Toll was a bit of a riff on Poe and had the strongest voice and character in the collection. Andromeda was a fun end-of-the-world story.

But overall, it didn't work for me. I felt the same way about Burke's Sour Candy (I went in with high expectations and found it fairly dull).