You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
wart 's review for:
For Today I Am a Boy
by Kim Fu
I received this book free through a GoodReads First Reads give away. (I also apparently can't spell "received")
Note: Throughout my review, I refer to the MC as Peter because this is the name used throughout the bulk of the novel. I do, however, use female pronouns because it is clear that Peter identifies as a woman.
I've been thinking about what to say about this book all afternoon at work, and I still am not really sure. I liked it. A lot. For the most part. Except for chapter 5, which was mind numbingly BORING.
The story is told more like...scenes in the life of Peter Huang. Which is actually pretty well done, and it all weaves together very nicely.
Peter's story is kind of heartbreaking. She's a first generation Canadian born to two Chinese immigrants - the only male child among four children. Therefore, Peter has his family's hopes and dreams - particularly her father's - placed upon her shoulders basically from birth.
Those hopes and dreams pretty much consist of growing up to be a successful, strong, married, man and father.
Peter's dreams run a little different.
Peter hides her dreams and wants, she lives the life laid out for her while taking secret moments to be who she feels herself to be - wearing an apron and cleaning, wearing her sisters old dresses and make-up...She does what she can alone, because she does not think the world will accept her.
One thing I think is most real in this book is that it isn't a story of triumph - it isn't Peter breaking through the stifling cocoon of societal norms and emerging as the woman she was meant to be. This is more, I think, about the loneliness of living a life that doesn't fit right. Of being someone who you don't feel.
And I think Kim Fu painted it beautifully.
Except chapter five, holy crap balls that chapter bored me to tears
Note: Throughout my review, I refer to the MC as Peter because this is the name used throughout the bulk of the novel. I do, however, use female pronouns because it is clear that Peter identifies as a woman.
I've been thinking about what to say about this book all afternoon at work, and I still am not really sure. I liked it. A lot. For the most part. Except for chapter 5, which was mind numbingly BORING.
The story is told more like...scenes in the life of Peter Huang. Which is actually pretty well done, and it all weaves together very nicely.
Peter's story is kind of heartbreaking. She's a first generation Canadian born to two Chinese immigrants - the only male child among four children. Therefore, Peter has his family's hopes and dreams - particularly her father's - placed upon her shoulders basically from birth.
Those hopes and dreams pretty much consist of growing up to be a successful, strong, married, man and father.
Peter's dreams run a little different.
One of our assignments was What I Want to Be When I Grow Up.
Working in studious silence, I drew myself as a Mommy.
I drew myself with a stiff halo of hair, swaddled babies around my feet. A satisfied smile from ear to ear. "I want to be a Mommy."
Peter hides her dreams and wants, she lives the life laid out for her while taking secret moments to be who she feels herself to be - wearing an apron and cleaning, wearing her sisters old dresses and make-up...She does what she can alone, because she does not think the world will accept her.
One thing I think is most real in this book is that it isn't a story of triumph - it isn't Peter breaking through the stifling cocoon of societal norms and emerging as the woman she was meant to be. This is more, I think, about the loneliness of living a life that doesn't fit right. Of being someone who you don't feel.
And I think Kim Fu painted it beautifully.