2.5
slow-paced

I’ll be honest, I had high hopes after the first half but once I hit that halfway mark it’s like the author just lost her own plot. She also mentioned Naomi Klein so much, I would suggest just saving yourself the time and read Klein. 

Right out of the gate, if you - in the year of our lord 2024 - state that the ADL is a legitimate source without a trace of irony? I immediately don’t trust you. I also am very disappointed in the treatment of the discussion surrounding Oct. 7. After chapter after chapter of very clear Opinions™️, to immediately start waffling and finger pointing to AI? You could have just left it out. You could have just not mentioned it because you said nothing and added nothing of substance. 

Secondly, there is an entire (lengthy!!) chapter about a specific, targetted campaign against the author's own organization, and it adds zero value to the discussion of invisible rulers and propaganda. Rather, it seems as though the author took the opportunity to defend herself and her organization’s activities against malicious actors and a hate campaign. Again - lost the plot. The history of "influencing" as a means of spreading information was probably the most interesting part of the book for me. The Russian troll farms, Gamergate and the 2020 elections felt more cobbled together and/or already over-analyzed with more extremely overlong chapters. 

Tl;dr - very repetitive, a slog to get through and doesn’t add much to the discourse. However if you are largely checked out of American politics, don’t understand how facts and fact-checking work, don’t engage in social media and need a dumbed-down version of current political events - THIS IS FOR YOU. Otherwise, skip it.