Take a photo of a barcode or cover
wart 's review for:
3.5 stars
You can read this and other reviews at Things I Find While Shelving
I wanted to love this.
OMG I wanted to love this so badly. I love the Sherlock Holmes stories. I love Elementary. I enjoy Sherlock (even if it pisses me off sometimes). I loved the movies with RDJ and Jude Law. I eat up all things Holmes like nobody’s business.
But this book.
It was good, but it wasn’t as awesome as I was hoping for.
Some of the stories are absolutely fantastic! A Scandal in Hobohemia is a super fun start to the anthology - not strictly Holmes and Watson, but they may as well. And it ends on a high note with Parallels - teenage girl Holmes and Watson? What’s not to love?! And in between are some real gems, my favorites being (in no particular order): The Lantern Men, A Study in Scarborough, The Small World of 221B, and The Final Conjuration (if you read nothing else in this book, read The Final Conjuration, it is amazing)
There were two I could not read - Half There/All There and The Patchwork Killer. I just couldn’t get into them. The characters didn’t feel right, which is frustrating, because I really did want to read everything in this anthology, but when you’re not into it, you’re not into it. And drug dealer John Watson is not something I buy ever (Half There/All There).
Over all, it’s an enjoyable read, definitely a good one for fellow Holmes nerds, but, like I said, despite some gems it isn’t amazing.
You can read this and other reviews at Things I Find While Shelving
I wanted to love this.
OMG I wanted to love this so badly. I love the Sherlock Holmes stories. I love Elementary. I enjoy Sherlock (even if it pisses me off sometimes). I loved the movies with RDJ and Jude Law. I eat up all things Holmes like nobody’s business.
But this book.
It was good, but it wasn’t as awesome as I was hoping for.
Some of the stories are absolutely fantastic! A Scandal in Hobohemia is a super fun start to the anthology - not strictly Holmes and Watson, but they may as well. And it ends on a high note with Parallels - teenage girl Holmes and Watson? What’s not to love?! And in between are some real gems, my favorites being (in no particular order): The Lantern Men, A Study in Scarborough, The Small World of 221B, and The Final Conjuration (if you read nothing else in this book, read The Final Conjuration, it is amazing)
There were two I could not read - Half There/All There and The Patchwork Killer. I just couldn’t get into them. The characters didn’t feel right, which is frustrating, because I really did want to read everything in this anthology, but when you’re not into it, you’re not into it. And drug dealer John Watson is not something I buy ever (Half There/All There).
Over all, it’s an enjoyable read, definitely a good one for fellow Holmes nerds, but, like I said, despite some gems it isn’t amazing.