orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

The Sunbearer Trials by Aiden Thomas
4.0
adventurous funny hopeful lighthearted tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

tldr/summary: 
The world has nice vibes and is very pleasant to be in, as long as you don’t think about it too hard. Once you do however, most aspects of it fall apart in one way or another. This problem however is compensated for by a truly stellar cast. Almost every named character in the story is full of personality and life. It’s way too easy to form an emotional bond with everyone, whether the characters are likeable or truly nasty. These people are engaged in a storyline with a mostly slow and unoriginal beginning, but after the first fifth the plot picks up pace and continuously becomes more tense and interesting until the very end. 

 Long version: 
The world in which the story of Teo and his friends takes place is a fictional world heavily themed after South American landscapes and native cultures and mythology. It is at every moment beautifully illustrated and the vibes of it all are amazing. Most places evoke exactly the feeling they are supposed to: warm coziness, messiness (both homely and unnerving) glorious and so on. 
However, the worldbuilding quickly starts to fall apart if you look too closely. It is sadly the weakest aspect of the novel. For starters, most names of gods, places and so on are really plain and uncreative. The goddess of love is called Amor, the sun god is called Sol, the labyrinth-like city is called Laberinto. That alone can easily take one out of the story at times. And that is before the story brings up very modern concepts like smartphones or a social media platform called ‘Instagrafio’, which clash heavily with the very fantastical and magical aspects of this world. But those are all minor problems. Things get more complicated when the story actually progresses into the titular Sunbearer Trials. 
Long ago, the supreme god Sol sacrificed themself to seal the evil gods away from the mortal world. Since then, every ten years, ten teenagers are chosen to compete in 5 trials. At the end of those trials, one of them is chosen to be killed and their soul is sacrificed to Sol. That way, Sol’s energy is replenished and they are able to hold off the evil gods for ten more years. Another chosen one becomes the Sunbearer and brings the essence of the sacrificed soul to each of the land’s temples. 
There are several problems with how this is executed. Most notably: Luna – the goddess who’s in charge of managing most of the trials – says in the opening ceremony that being sacrificed is a bigger honor than being the Sunbearer, given how their soul is what actually keeps the evil gods at bay. However no one in the entire world seems to actually believe that. They have to sacrifice the person who comes in last place because that is the only way to motivate the contestants to do good in the trial. 
It makes sense that the teens who’s lives are actually at stake don’t like it, but no one else seems to like it either, not the mortals in this world, the priests who work in service of the gods, not even the actual gods themselves. Does Luna herself not have children? Would she scold her children if they put effort into not being in last place? The event is even named after the Sunbearer, the person who survives the ritual. There is also a point when the story implies you are not allowed to show the ritual killing on fantasy youtube, even though it is the apex of this world’s most important holiday. 
All this becomes especially shaky considering: This is not just some ceremony the mortals of this world made up – the gods are actually real. The ritual sacrifice serves a practical purpose: It stops the forces of evil from destroying the world. Before their sacrifice, Sol had a husband and he is still around and makes his children participate in the trials. We know for sure all the legends surrounding these trials are real. Luna is actually right, being sacrificed is the more important part of the ceremony. So why is that role given to the person who absolutely fumbled the worthiness test? Everyone in this world definitely knows how crucial the trials are to the continued existence of everything – especially the people participating in it – yet no one acts like that is the case. That is the core contradiction of the Sunbearer Trials. 
It is in fact so glaring that the characters themselves actively address this twice in the story, yet the logic behind how the rules are laid out is never explained. When Teo points out that the winner should be sacrificed, the best counter arguments the others managed to come up with are “You’re wrong.” and “I disagree.”. Because Teo very astutely and correctly identified how nonsensical and contradictory the rules of his world are. 


And that is even though Teo is kind of an idiot in the beginning. He is the main protagonist and son of a lower class goddess. Because of this, he did not go to the academy where the children of more powerful higher class gods trained for the Trials their whole lives. Teo knows from the beginning that he cannot simply win the trials by playing them straight. He has to game the system. But then he simply doesn’t. At the end of both the first and second trial, the Goddess Luna reminds everyone that how well you do in the Heroism Trials isn’t determined simply by completing the trials, but also by how heroic you tried to be during them. Yet Teo seems to not understand what she means by that and goes on competing in the Trials as if he were a golden god, even though he knows that’s a fool’s errand. 
He also seems terribly oblivious to what is happening to Aurelio behind the scenes. It gets to the point that even Aurelio himself seems to be annoyed by Teo’s stubborn, childish ignorance. Thankfully, as the story progresses onward, Teo continually becomes less and less annoying on his route to being the genuinely lovable hero Sol saw in him all along. 
Still, his initial conflict with Aurelio is quite tiring, because it is really obvious what is happening with him and where his story will go. That being said, despite its predictability, Aurelio’s character and arc are really compelling and emotionally investing; not to mention that the relationship development between Teo and Aurelio feels really nice and natural. He is definitely a highlight in a world full of magnificent characters. 
Because pretty much every character in this world is impressively well executed. That is true for the heroes as well as the less relevant side characters and the genuinely nasty antagonists. Every being that populates Sol’s realm is full of personality and can show it off in very few actions and words, but there is also a lot going on beneath this easy to understand surface. Many characters act in ways that imply more complexities than are relevant for the story, for example the novel implies on a few occasions that the friendship between Marino and Dezi is a bit more romantic (or at least more passionate) than their bonds with their other friends. 
Of the ten trialists, Teo and his two friends form the protagonist squad with three mean rivals to match. The other four contestants are only background noise most of the time. They are however still some of the most vibrant and interesting characters in this world. By the half-way point, the reader has developed a strong relationship with pretty much all of them – so it isn’t too bothering that this supposedly deadly tournament never makes them believe any of these lives are in any real danger until the very end. 
The only real exception to this is Xio. Though he is a character with a rich personality and storyline, he is mostly annoying a lot of the time. During the trials, he is so pathetic and useless, it feels like he tries to throw and get himself killed on purpose. And he isn’t lovable enough for it to make up for his mistakes and shortcomings. 
Another noteworthy thing is that the cast is very colorful and diverse, not just in personality. The characters display a large variety of body types, gender identities and some characters are implied to be gay (which will probably become much more explicit in the sequel). Dezi is actually deaf which is really nicely executed and rather charming. 


However, the way Teo’s trans identity is executed feels a bit clunky and heavy handed. The fact that he's part human, part bird seems to act as an allegory for being trans – even though Teo is already trans. 
This starts with how in the beginning, it is mentioned that Teo wears a binder. But it's not to hide his chest – he already had top surgery. It's to hide his wings, which have the color of 'female birds' even though his mother's wings are also what has been defined as male coloration. And then during the very first trial, Teo’s wings change color towards those of male birds for no reason. This event is not understood by anyone in the story and does not get explained until the very end. 
It feels as if Teo was originally meant to not have had top surgery yet, but then the breasts became inconvenient to the writing, so the exploration of gender dysphoria was shifted elsewhere. But having a winged character not fly around when his life is under constant threat was also kind of stupid. Originally, it seems as if this is used to explain why Teo is so untrained at flying, but then he is just good at flying almost immediately and his stamina is also always just enough for whatever flying he needs to do. 
Then after the second trial, the characters have a conversation about how Teo's bird body works (e.g. asking him if he has hollow bones, how he goes to the bathroom etc.). Again, this is clearly supposed to be an allegory for the life experiences of a trans person, but it's so weirdly shifted towards Teo being half bird. (Also no one seems to ever question how the non-human aspects of demigods other than Teo work.) This is especially weird since one page later, Teo has a genuinely well executed conversation about being trans with his younger transmasc friend. It's interesting, insightful, wholesome and emotionally touching. Why was the author so intent on hiding the exploration of being trans behind Teo's bird body when they’re also willing to just play it straight? 


The plot itself starts off rather stereotypical and not very interesting. A lot of focus is put on building up Teo’s hometown and characters that never appear ever again. It is rather slow and low stakes. Even as the actual plot starts introducing itself, things still largely remain uninteresting. The first half of the book heavily favors downtime over action in the trials. And said downtime is rarely used to do a lot of interesting stuff. Example, after the first trial, the main character squad spends several pages strategizing to figure out that fire people are weak to water and the bully character is not very smart. That Ocelo is an idiot has already been firmly established by now; it would have been genuinely interesting to hear what weakness you get from the ability to transform into one of the most dangerous animals in the world. 
By the time of the second trial however, both the plot and the tension pick up pace and the author has a good grasp of making things constantly more investing, tense and unnerving as the story goes on, without major dips or putting the characters into so much peril that it disengages the reader. The second and third trial are great, but by the time the fourth and fifth trial roll around, it becomes really hard to put down the book if instead you could keep reading and find out what happens next to these people you’ve grown so fond of by now. 


Spoilers! 


Every now and then, characters behave uncharacteristically toxic. However it turns out this is actually really brilliant foreshadowing for a later twist. In parts it is so subtle it wouldn’t be surprising if people don’t catch every moment of foreshadowing even in a reread, because the level of toxicity is adjusted depending on which character is affected. The heroes of the story are limited to one or two unusually snarky comments – it is only the characters established as mean antagonists that have more violent outbursts. It’s impressive how well this aspect of the story is executed. Still the sequel needs to do some heavy lifting to retroactively make Ocelo and Auristela nice guys who wouldn’t be better utilized as genuinely nasty people; especially since Xio will probably also be given a redemption arc. The story would definitely loose something if there were virtually no bad people in it except for the three evil gods.