An interesting premise, if a bit far-fetched. I feel like some of the relationships are a little forced, as is the "humour" with the Endo twins. The real star of the show is the art. Most panels are gorgeous—Gaydos does a terrific job. There's room for improvement in the page layout, though. Sometimes I had to reread a spread a couple times to figure out whether the panels flowed across the whole two pages or down one page and then the next. A couple of times I couldn't figure out what the right answer was. So maybe the book is a little less than a 4, but it's worth picking up just to stare at.