This is the first in the series I've read so I'm not sure how much the previous stories might play into Caitlyn and Tanner's interactions.  I'm sure they've made appearances but I'm not sure how much that should influence reader's reaction to their love story.  Overall, though, the story does stand alone pretty well.  Mims does a fantastic job of making sure that new readers like me can keep up with anything that might trickle in from those other stories.  

There is definitely tension between the two.  Caitlyn has never warmed up to her sister's husband - he's all around a little too much for her and she never felt like he was worthy of being her sister's husband. 

I'm an only child so I have a pretty hard time grasping the intricacies of sibling relationships in stories like this.  Caitlyn resents her sister and feels like she's always played second to her - getting all her hand-me-downs, big and small.  But she also loves her and holds her in very high regard, going so far to think that the man her sister loved wasn't good enough to marry her.  Logically it makes sense but there's just so much turbulence there and it bleeds over into her dealings with Tanner.

Who is having enough issues of his own dealing with life after the death of his wife.  It's not been easy and he's now feeling pressure from his own (awful) parents, which leads him to falling into a fake relationship with his sister-in-law.  He's very aware that she's never really liked him and having to rely on her help is complicated.  Made even more so when he starts seeing her as more than just his wife's sister.  

Mims does well by Caitlyn.  I think she finally gets a chance to put some of her emotional demons to rest and come to terms with her feelings about herself.  It's hard for her to face certain things after so many years but she does.  I think Tanner does a good job of facing a few of his own issues (although he does have a few fabulous man moments that make you want to smack him a little).  His own childhood and history has given him a few doubts and unfortunately a lack of good communication skills on both their parts just feeds into that, and for Caitlyn as well.  They eventually get things figured out but it takes a bit and some soul-searching for them to get there :) 

There's a lot of drama on everyone's part in Mistletoe and quite a few people need to learn to talk AND listen.  Quite a bit of their troubles could have been avoided with a little better communication but Mims gives us very human characters with very human faults.  (I know I'm AWFUL about communicating some things!)  It makes it real and difficult and, most of all, enjoyable to read.   

*** I voluntarily read a Review Copy of this book. All opinions stated are solely my own and no one else’s. ***