birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Honey: A Novel by Isabel Banta
3.5

I really enjoyed this one so much—it’s a millennial’s pop culture loving dream. Very bubblegum popping, CD collecting, postered up bedroom walls and singing in the mirror type feeling thing. 

Amber Young is dying to make it, she doesn’t really fit in that well and when she’s discovered at a middle school talent show, her single mother really tries to make her dream work for her. Nothing really comes of it, she’s not the right look, not the right talent, until by chance she gets plucked out of obscurity to be a member of a new girl group. Honey follows her as she navigates her career, competitive friendships, love, and the image the label wants her to cultivate. 

I really loved the way Banta told this story—often the chapters were followed by different media like interviews which showed the ways in which Amber was being misinterpreted or used for gossip mag fodder. I loved the PR of it all and like Daisy Jones & The Six, the behind the scenes making of music. All of that was done so well and if anything I was disappointed there wasn’t more of it. I also think, with what we know of Nickelodeon and pop stars memoirs of the time, this could have gone a lot deeper and darker. I’d have liked to see some of the issues we know existed been grappled with more, so often it felt a little shallow to me, a little too easy. Lastly, this book was so relentlessly smutty and it became so distracting considering it added nothing to the story and felt really not in keeping with the rest of the book. It’s almost, like with Amber, the author was told to sex it up because that’s what sells. Just a weird vibe. 

But, I love pop stars, celebrity reimaginings and pop culture so this still really worked for me. The audiobook narration wasn’t my favourite though, the music played behind readings of lyrics was so cringe and all the smut and then she didn’t differentiate enough between voices sometimes so I’d lose track of who was talking…. 😬 

I still think this one is so fun, I’d just avoid the audio and go in expecting quite a bit of smut lol.

Thanks to @librofm and @macmillan.audio @celadonbooks for the audio review copy.