That one wasn't good. First it isn't a manga in anyway (except the fact that it's black and white...). It doesn't read the way manga does and it hasn't the illustration style of a manga (Manga have many style but we still feel a common direction in most of those I read that we don't here). The story was not really interesting either. Maybe if you're a die hard fan of Charmed you would hvae a different opinion, maybe not, but I didn't enjoy this one at all!