You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Vanishing World
by Sayaka Murata
challenging
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
N/A
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Definitely a WTF did I just read moment—but not in a good way.
This was such an unpleasant, sterile yet overly sexual reading experience I couldn’t enjoy it for a second. We follow Amane through three periods of her life—sexual awakening, marriage/coming of age, and motherhood—but in an alternate future where copulation has almost been totally replaced with artificial insemination, the dissolution of the family structure and a stark purity culture (but not religious).
The problems for me begin with a narrative that relies on boring repetitive dialogue, barely existent plot and over reliance on bizarre sexual descriptions/experiences; and continues on to achieve seemingly very little but making me feel like I need a shower.
I really like the premise here—but the execution was not for me, the writing (or translation?) was so bare bones, so off-putting, it rode the line between surreal body horror without quit tipping into a place that unnerved me in a way I like, instead it created an atmosphere that was super boring and kinda queasy but not quite eerie or weird enough to be enjoyable (for me) the focus was on reiterating the same info over and over and beating the same scenario to death—ie Amane’s desire to bone all her boyfriends like a total freak, ew no one does that anymore.
I thought ideas surrounding relying on fictional characters to fulfil your romantic and sexual appetites were interesting and worth interrogating, the ideas of humanity evolving to a place without family and what that would look like compelling, but I just don’t think this book did enough. It felt very surface level, and just losing track of the point it was trying to make? Somehow? I dunno. And then the ending? Truly wtf 😳 I can’t say this makes me want to ever pick up another book of hers. 😒
My thanks to NetGalley and Grove Press for the review copy.
This was such an unpleasant, sterile yet overly sexual reading experience I couldn’t enjoy it for a second. We follow Amane through three periods of her life—sexual awakening, marriage/coming of age, and motherhood—but in an alternate future where copulation has almost been totally replaced with artificial insemination, the dissolution of the family structure and a stark purity culture (but not religious).
The problems for me begin with a narrative that relies on boring repetitive dialogue, barely existent plot and over reliance on bizarre sexual descriptions/experiences; and continues on to achieve seemingly very little but making me feel like I need a shower.
I really like the premise here—but the execution was not for me, the writing (or translation?) was so bare bones, so off-putting, it rode the line between surreal body horror without quit tipping into a place that unnerved me in a way I like, instead it created an atmosphere that was super boring and kinda queasy but not quite eerie or weird enough to be enjoyable (for me) the focus was on reiterating the same info over and over and beating the same scenario to death—ie Amane’s desire to bone all her boyfriends like a total freak, ew no one does that anymore.
I thought ideas surrounding relying on fictional characters to fulfil your romantic and sexual appetites were interesting and worth interrogating, the ideas of humanity evolving to a place without family and what that would look like compelling, but I just don’t think this book did enough. It felt very surface level, and just losing track of the point it was trying to make? Somehow? I dunno. And then the ending? Truly wtf 😳 I can’t say this makes me want to ever pick up another book of hers. 😒
My thanks to NetGalley and Grove Press for the review copy.