illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

This Immaculate Body by Emma van Straaten
4.0
dark sad tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Loveable characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Alice has been cleaning Tom's flat every Wednesday for the past year. Every fingerprint wiped from glass, every pillow fluffed and hair swept up, drives her deeper into infatuation. They're soulmates, Alice knows it from the fluttering of her heart, she just needs to actually meet him and their perfect life together can begin. Right? 

This is a spiral into the beating, bloody heart of obsession. Alice is the ultimate unreliable narrator, existing in a web of delusion and lies that increasingly fail to square with reality. Little slips that let you know things are Not Okay, no matter what Alice pretends, are worked throughout the text to fantastic effect, ratcheting up narrative tension.

Tom's character is deliberately 2D: a flat plane she projects her fixation onto. References to him are capitalised (He, His) with Alice's spirals of reverie taking on an almost archaic tone of religious devotion; his love is the missing piece Alice needs to begin her true life. To be worthy. Accepted. Normal. 

'Unhinged women' books like this can be tricky. What makes or breaks a book in this subgenre for me is: does the character feel like the butt of the joke? This isn't the same as them being likeable, but when 'unhinged' behaviour ultimately stems from some sort of trauma, I don't want to feel like I'm supposed to laugh at them. Van Straaten navigates this well and treats Alice with tenderness, despite her many flaws. She's haunted by an incident from her teenage years that has calcified her at that point in time — she's petulant and immature, catty, and devastatingly, harrowingly insecure. Her violent self-loathing, especially directed at her mixed-race heritage, may be familiar to anyone who grew up with 90s/2000s beauty standards. Despite her objectively awful behaviour, I felt a deep pity for how unlovable and wrong she felt herself to be.

Tense, bruisingly tender, and genuinely creepy, this story of demented devotion had me on the edge of my seat. My heart hurt for Alice, blinkered by her pining to the love she already had... but I'm also deeply scared of her.