You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

maxarcreads's profile picture

maxarcreads 's review for:

Her Dark Grace by Rae Valtera
3.75

I am giving this a 3.75. I think this was a really cool concept of a book and I liked the world the author built as it is different from the fantasy worlds I unusually read which are usually based on Celtic mythology, so I really enjoyed this change. I also enjoyed a lot of the representation I saw with Poly relationships, bi representation as well as hidden disability representation. I think that was all done very well. 

I think what stopped it from being a 4 or high for me is that I just didn't connect to the FMC as much as I would like. The cover and tropes thought I was going to be reading a badass, snarky, take no shit, grumpy warrior woman who will be taking on this kingdom that is set out to kill people like her and is so deeply rooted in a religion where it is okay to kill babies and try to dismantle it from the inside. And for me that is just not what I got from the FMC. I just kept waiting for her to do something anything to step up and push back but for a lot of this book she is just waiting to be crowned which takes forever in this kingdom bc then as she sees it, she can make real change. But as she spends time in this kingdom, she sees that this religion and the gods are so deeply rooted that she may not be able to even do anything when she is crowned because everyone hates her and sees her as evil and wants her gone. So, she does nothing really after that. Being part of an elite guard and being around the other royal family and knowing there are some sympathizers within her new kingdom if she couldn't confront the issue head-on, I wish she had been covert and tried to start a rebellion or something but really, she had no plans for anything outside of getting crowned. She didn't even keep up her warrior training or exercises until like the middle/end of her time there where she admitted to being out of shape. I mean I know she was locked in her room for the most part but do some sit ups, run around in room something anything to stay in shape. I just wanted more from her especially with her being so qualified for overt or covert ways of building a rebellion to bring about change even if it was just laying the groundwork for a long-term operation as taking down gods and such a deeply rooted religion would take time. I will say there was a point at about 80% I think it was into the book where I finally saw all those qualities and I was like YES this is what I was waiting for where was this woman before.

Overall, I do think the concept and plot were interesting and I while I liked it, I think the last 20% was my favorite of the book because that is when I could connect to the FMC, and she was actually fighting back. 

So, this book is about Eirlys who is shadow marked and what that means in her world is that as a baby her mother had to smuggle her to the southern realm as being born in the northern realm would have meant her death as their religion calls for all shadow born infants to killed. So now she spends her nights prowling the border between the realms to rescue as many babies as she can. But one night goes wrong when in trying to rescue a baby she is confronted by a northern priest but is able to escape with the baby and her life but there were consequences she will have to live with for the rest of her life. While dealing with the consequences of that night she comes to learn that the king and queen of the northern kingdom were assassinated, and they will be unable to crown who they thought was their next queen because the next in line of their succession is in fact... her. It turns out her mother who she knew was really her aunt was hiding that she was the queen's sister and had kidnapped her as a baby when it was revealed she was shadow born for her safety which means she is the true heir of the Northern Kingdom. Rather than abdicate she decides to take her rightful place in the northern kingdom to hopefully change and dismantle it from the inside to save future shadow born babies from being killed. But when on her journey home and when she arrives the attempts on her life prove this will not be an easy mission so in an "effort" to keep her safe the gods put her under their care of one of their priests who is none other than the one she recently confronted as he tried to carry out the law of the gods. But as they spend time together the hate that she has for him starts to be chipped away just like the faith he has for his gods especially as he has a dark secret that the gods plan to use to against her which may end up being a fate far crueler than death. 

I received an ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.