I just finished and it's 5 stars for me easily. I could give it 5 just on vibes alone but I am obsessed with the characters and the not your standard type of characters. I also liked the balance between being cosy and having some level of stakes. This for sure is my kind of cosy. I loved the mer babies, and Meep, and the cloud tree spirits! and I want my own Pine Cone Coven. I must be getting soft in my old age but swoon, swoon, swoon!