Fourth Read (September 2023):
4.5 still stands. I still adore this series, LJ + PK, the Song girls along with the drama of growing apart from your childhood friends. This series is definitely a comfort read for sure.

Third Read (February 2021):
4.5⭐️
What I’ve said before. All of it.♥️

Second Read (February 2020):
4.5⭐️
I am keeping my rating the same. I still have the same feelings about everything in my first review so I’ll keep it short-
I am still a PK stan, although if the snow scene is cut out of the movie, I will riot!
But also Team Kitty?! Yes ma’am.


First Read (May 2019):
4.5⭐️
Umm okay Johnny coming in hot with his cute self! I absolutely adored him😍
I disliked seeing our sweet PK loyal to a fault when it comes to (“the witch with a b”) Gen. We see it tear his relationship apart by keeping secrets & I hope he gets it together in book 3.
Also Stormy?! I don’t think I have disliked a character as much as I dislike her. Stormy’s dialogue was difficult to get through & I almost stopped reading because of her, but I’m glad I did because LJ’s story is one I need to continue on with!
I still want her wardrobe and baking skills in my life and I can’t wait to see how her story concludes in the next one.