shealea's profile picture

shealea 's review for:

1.0

Review in a bullet-point format:

- Okay, wow, this was heaps of awful and terrible.
- Dialogue that was either ridiculously sappy monologue or laughably bad dirty talk.
- Unnecessary drama that was blown out of proportion for the sake of extending the plot!!!
- Pet names that made me cringe so hard I'm fairly certain I started an earthquake somewhere (i.e. Dr. Asshole, Boyfriend, Sexy Pussy Fucker).

"So do you mind, Dr. Asshole, Boyfriend, Sexy Pussy Fucker, Eli?" She smiled so wide I couldn't help but smile back.


- Honestly, how in the world can anyone fall in love with someone who not only said that dating you is pitiful but also said:

"Yes! Especially compared to who I actually was dating! Not only was she beautiful and classy, but also extremely intelligent. How do you compare to that?"


- At one point, Gwen literally told Eli that she does not want to share him with his daughter. How is that okay?

"I can see it so clearly, me not seeing you because of work and then when I do you have to be with your daughter. Besides, I still have things I want to do with my career too... I'm selfish, Eli. I don't like that I am, but I don't want to share you with Hannah or your daughter or anyone. I feel like they are standing between us, like they are the thing between us... "


- A TRANS CHARACTER'S SUICIDE WAS USED AS A MERE PLOT DEVICE!!! And being a transperson was likened to wanting to pursue a career in music. Oh my fucking god. (See spoiler to read the actual passage.)

Spoiler
Putting my plate down on his coffee table, I faced him. "I'm going to tell you something sad, but please don't worry about if I'm still hurt or anything like that. For the most part, I'm really okay." I could tell he felt a little lost. "I'm only saying this because you fought with your brother. So when I was twelve, my brother came back from college and told my parents he didn't feel like a guy. He said he hated looking at this person in the mirror that wasn't him. It was killing him on the inside. He planned to become a female, and my father lost it." I whispered that last part.

"He was so angry he almost had a heart attack. He told my brother to never come back to his house ever again... not until he 'got his head on straight'. My brother, he tried. He tried as hard as he could to change himself to be more like what my father wanted, but that just made him hate himself more. No one talked about it. Then, a year later, he committed suicide, and only a few days after that, we each got letters in the mail from him. Mine was him telling me how much he loved me, and wanted me to be the best Guinevere in the history of Guineveres, and also to take care of his puppy, Taigi. To my parents, he said that he loved them, even though he knew he disgusted them, and that he hoped they could one day forgive him. My father cried for weeks, and my mom couldn't even get out of bed." I hated talking about my past. I had told no one this, not even Sebastian.

"When I go home and hug my father, I always wonder if he regrets what he said to my brother, if he would have preferred to have two daughters instead of one daughter and a dead son. The only reason I'm saying this to you - and I'm sorry for making this evening so depressing - is because hearing Logan felt like I was hearing my brother. The same thing, just this time it's about music. Is it really the same? No. Yes. I'm not sure. All I know is, we all get one life, and it's hard enough without the people we love trying to stop us from completing our dreams. Could he go out there and completely fail as a musician? Sure. It happens to millions of people, and I'm sure there will be more than enough people who will tell him he isn't any good, or that he will never make it. Believe me, I know, because I've met all of them."


- TL;DR: Gwen and Eli are both horrible, horrible people that bring out the toxic in each other.
- Not much of a romance; this was very lust-driven and sex-centered.
- Plenty of badly written sex scenes.
- Ultimately unsatisfying, especially that god-awful epilogue.
- I won't ever recommend this literary garbage to anyone.

Content/Trigger warnings:
Infidelity and affair; suicide of a trans character; possible misgendering; transphobia; sex; surprise pregnancy.

Quick disclosure: I received a digital ARC of That Thing Between Eli & Gwen from the publisher (via NetGalley) in exchange for an honest review.

Actual rating: 1 star
* Find more of my bookish shenanigans in my natural habitat!