This was a really cute YA holiday-themed anthology. Overall, I enjoyed most of the stories (I will admit there were a few duds) and am glad I read this title. My favorite story of the bunch was the first one by Rainbow Rowell. Having the best story (by my judgment) be the first story a reader experiences can definitely impact how they view the rest of the collection. If I had put together this book, I probably would have changed the order of the stories for this reason. I was also impressed by Matt de la Pena's story and will definitely seek out more of his writing in the future. My True Love Gave to Me was the perfect book to read right before Christmas and certainly helped me get into the holiday spirit!