hongjoongie's profile picture

hongjoongie 's review for:

Motherhood by Sheila Heti
4.0
dark funny hopeful informative inspiring reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Why are we still having children? Why was it important for that doctor that I did? A woman must have children because she must be occupied. When I think of all the people who want to forbid abortions, it seems it can only mean one thing not that they want this new person in the world, but that they want that woman to be doing the work of child-rearing more than they want her to be doing anything else. There is something threatening about a woman who is not occupied with children. There is something at-loose-ends feeling about such a woman. What is she going to do instead? What sort of trouble will she make? 
 
The egoism of childbearing is like the egoism of colonizing a country-both carry the wish of imprinting yourself on the world, and making it over with your values, and in your image. How assaulted I feel when I hear that a person has had three children, four, five, more... It feels greedy, overbearing and rude-an arrogant spreading of those selves. 
 
To have a child is like being a city with a mountain in the middle. Everyone sees the mountain. Everyone in the city is proud of the mountain. The city is built around it. A mountain, like a child, displays something real about the value of that town. In a life in which there is no child, no one knows anything about your life's meaning. They might suspect it doesn't have one-no centre it is built around. Your life's value is invisible, like the contexts of that young driver's friends. How wonderful to tread an invisible path, where what matters most can hardly be seen. 
 
Besides, there are so many kinds of life to give birth to in this world, apart from a literal human life. And there are children everywhere, and parents needing help everywhere, and so much work to be done, and lives to be affirmed that are not necessarily the lives we would have chosen, had we started again. The whole world needs to be mothered. I don't need to invent a brand new life to give the warming effect to my life I imagine mothering will bring. There are lives and duties everywhere just crying out for a mother. That mother could be you.

As someone who has no interest in having children, I really enjoyed this book, a unique blend of fiction, memoir, and essay exploring what motherhood is and the impact of choosing to be or not to be a mother. Some very interesting discussions on the conflict between producing offspring and producing art, motherhood as art, and passing on a maternal legacy through creative output. Does being a mother foreclose creative expression? Does it enhance it? Or is producing art just one of the many paths to motherhood one can take? I also liked the idea of nurturing backwards and taking care of those already here than only looking forward to care for those conceived. I read some criticism that the book is too self-indulgent and/or self-reflective, and that confuses me because writing is almost always a therapeutic process and has and continues to be used to reflect and express internal turmoil, regardless of form or genre. I also don’t understand criticism that the book only focuses on one pov (a cishet white woman). That’s what the narrator is so… not sure she should occupy other spaces or try to elaborate on other lived experiences too much. Oddly, I noticed quite a few typos/errors, so someone needs a new editor.