Like most books that are divided into two parts, a "before" and "after", I find that the first half of the book was good, while the 2nd fails to captivate me (a few times I debated weather I should keep reading).

Although most people seem to focus on the stereotypical way in which this book addresses Russian immigrant, I would like to add that, being an immigrant myself, no, people dont just leave their culture behind when they come to a new country. And although I agree that having a father that drinks vodka all day is a bit too much, I wouldn't go as far as say its unrealistic. Maybe greatly exaggerated, but not unrealistic.

While reading this book, I had a constant feeling of discomfort. It felt awkward reading on about young Valclav, and his relationship with Lena, but more so when we learn about Lena's past, before she end up at her Aunt's.

I assume that was the intention of the book, to keep you in a sort of horrified trance to read more. Which I must say it did, but I did finish the book wondering if I should have stopped at part one and not have dealt with the dull and predictable ending.

I generously gave this 3 starts, but later decided 2 stars was a more fitting rating.