It was okay? I don’t hate Phillip, he honestly seems like there’s more depth to him that the author just didn’t tap into but it wasn’t done well. He seems like he could be wonderful but he’s just kind of bland. Eloise is kind of just annoying in this book? I thought her relationship with the kids was endearing but her and Phillip were just boring. If more about the letters was included I would’ve liked them more. Penelope not even being in the book or mentioned until the naming of their child was also annoying. I wasn’t bored though so I’ll give it a 3.