Drew and Shane have always been best friends. When new girl Stevie enters their lives, and they both have feelings for her, that could all change. With the flip of a coin their lives will be altered in different ways.

When I read this synopsis, I totally got Sliding Doors vibes which was a movie I loved. I thought the story being told in dual timelines would be a great way to see how the coin toss would change things, but I wish it was told differently. The first half of the book was one flip and the second half was the other. I think it would have preferred if the stories overlapped to get a better idea of the characters and their development throughout.

My other issue was that I didn’t really like Drew or Stevie. Shane was a better character in my opinion. He was willing to do anything for his best friend which is admirable.

I listened to the audiobook and enjoyed the narrators Bailey Carr, Dan Bitner, and Michael Crouch. I felt that were each suited well for the characters they voiced.

Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for an advanced listeners copy in exchange for my honest review.