3.5 stars

This book is the first in a trilogy with a lot of potential—Nocturna, specifically, is a Latinx-inspired fantasy about a couple of unlikely allies coming together to fight a unique battle in a classic light vs dark scenario. The protagonists, Alfie and Finn, are polar opposites yet equally complex and intriguing characters. The magic system is interesting but still easy to understand, the world of San Cristóbal fascinating. I love the idea that magic has colors and I also love the mythology Motayne effortlessly wove into her world.

Where there’s good, there’s usually bad as well, to some extent. This is no exception. I would’ve liked to know a bit more about what’s outside of San Cristóbal, as we’re given that beautiful map on the inside cover but no information regarding any of those other countries. The pacing was uneven. And although a proper romance didn’t actually develop between Alfie and Finn, the feelings they had for each other at the end of the novel felt random.

While on the subject of the ending, I appreciate the way Motayne wrapped up the plot while still leaving the protagonists open to more adventures. I’m not super interested in the sequel, but I’m curious and do plan to give it a chance. I’d advise anyone interested in Nocturna to do the same, as it’s a fun read despite its flaws. And to those who say this book is a Shades of Magic ripoff, just stop. V.E. Schwab isn’t the only person allowed to write soft boys and tough girls.

CW: child abuse & manipulation, death, grief, blood, magical violence