hongjoongie's profile picture

hongjoongie 's review for:

The English Teacher by Lily King
4.5
dark emotional hopeful mysterious reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Vida often thought that if her mother were the man and her father the woman they would be happy together. If her mother didn't have to conceal from the world her intelligence and ambition, if her father wasn't expected to squeeze money out of his dreams, there might be peace. But pressed up so close to their pain, Vida learned that true life was in books, life that was, no matter the foulness and misery, beautiful and symmetrical and comforting. 
 
One thing she admired about Hardy was the inevitability of his tragedies. He was right up there with the Greeks, the way Tess for example picked up steam. You felt the first spasm of motion in the very first scene, then with each subsequent scene the tragedy gathered power. But life itself was nothing like that. In life the lack of inevitability—the lack of any design at all—was the tragedy. 
 
How did you go about convincing yourself that this instant right now was real and solid when it felt so flimsy in your hands, bleeding into the next, porous, full of holes and puckers, and the mind was so bad at recording anything correctly? How did you make this moment right here with the hummingbird moving now onto the flat yellow flower and the voices dwindling toward the kitchen and her own quick breaths pushing up against her hand—how did you cut that into a granite block and slide it perfectly into place beside all the others? 
 
It was all about courage. To live even a day on this earth required courage. All these things they read in school—the Odyssey, Beowulf, Huckleberry Finn—were all about courage, but the teacher never said, You may not have to kill a Cyclops or a dragon but you will need just as much courage to get through each day. 
 
This was really good. I’m in awe of how accurately and acutely Lily King portrays grief, trauma, and how hard it is to heal from life’s most damaging moments. I absolutely loved being inside Vida’s and Peter’s heads, and there are so many tense and poignant scenes. I also loved the life-imitates-art theme running throughout. Reading other reviews, I’m confused why people don’t like or sympathize with Vida. Having read Tess of the d’Urbervilles, I already knew what the “twist” was and assumed what had happened to Vida going in, so I can completely understand why she would be so guarded and struggle expressing her emotions. For those who haven’t read Tess… I still don’t get why someone wouldn’t like Vida. People are complex and our actions are often influenced by our experiences, and King demonstrates this so well through Vida and the other characters.