This was my favorite book of this trilogy it was wrapped up well and by the end everything made sense. I loved the characters especially John and I like the whole group I liked what Charlie ended up being that just made sense once you put it all together. I loved the story it was an amazing conclusion to one of my favorite stories the writing was so good there were plenty of good scares and it was really thrilling loved it so much. So overall I loved this book so much that I really want more.