4 stars - I'm not sure what I expected from this one, but the plot was not at all what I imagined. I enjoyed the abbey setting, Brielle as a character, and zephyrus, too. The Under wasn't my favorite setting to read, very creepy, but the plot moved quickly enough and was action packed enough that I didn't worry too much about it. This one definitely left me emotional at times. The characters had a lot of growth, and I really enjoyed the relationships between the characters.