birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Good Neighbors by Sarah Langan
3.5

The Long Island suburbs where everything was supposed to be sunshine and upward mobility for ex-pageant queen Gertie and her now sober washed up rockstar husband Arlo, their kids foul mouthed Julie and likely on the spectrum Larry. Everything seemed to be headed that way, acceptance, despite being decidedly outsiders due to the friendship struck between Gertie and block head-bitch Rhea and their two daughters. But then, one night, too many drinks are had and some dark secrets are shared too soon and things start to go to shit. A sinkhole opens (my husband’s actual nightmare fear) and a kid falls inside, accusations of sexual abuse are thrown around and reputations and then lives are at stake. 

The whole thing is manic—set in a near future during a heatwave, playing with the psychological terror of minds gone a little wild from the heat or maybe sinkhole fumes or from the suburbs itself—we know people die, we don’t know who or why and how we get there is a RIDE. I didn’t love the false sexual accusation narrative, the book lost points with that for me, but Rhea’s perspective was CHILLING and fascinating and the other characters endearing. I was in it to the end, surprises around every corner. I love the way the setting is almost a character and how reputation and gossip can become such a heady dangerous thing. How hard it is to go against the grain.

I really enjoyed this thriller, despite that plot point that rubbed me the wrong way. Rhea as a character was worth the other missteps. 

I actually only listened to this on audiobook because it was narrated by Nicole Lewis, who also partly narrated The House of Eve, she’s so good. Definitely worth the listen.