Take a photo of a barcode or cover
dckathleen 's review for:
The Personal Librarian
by Marie Benedict, Victoria Christopher Murray
informative
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Belle was a fascinating woman, a Black woman passing as white in the early 1900's and becoming JP Morgan's personal librarian. She was so much more than a librarian though, purchasing books and manuscripts at auctions, using her self taught expertise to evaluate and authenticate manuscripts, and constantly juggling being the only woman and also hiding her true identity. I thought it was so interesting that she developed her style as being fashionable and flirtatious after being raised to fade into the background as much as possible. She was obviously brilliant and savvy, but also constantly troubled by her need to hide her true identity.
In some ways I feel like this book focused too much on Belle's inner life, which was all conjecture, and felt repetitive over time. Obviously some of that was necessary. I would have loved to learn more about the research she did, and the books she bought, and how she negotiated her professional life. That's probably my fault for reading this instead of a biography of her life.
Overall the book was probably about 20% too long. That said, I'm still glad to have read it and to have learned about Belle Decosta Greene. I like that the authors stuck to historical facts within the story. I feel like I got a sense of what her balancing act might have been like...both as a Black woman in a white world and as a person whose family had modest means surrounded by Morgans and other Gilded Age families.
In some ways I feel like this book focused too much on Belle's inner life, which was all conjecture, and felt repetitive over time. Obviously some of that was necessary. I would have loved to learn more about the research she did, and the books she bought, and how she negotiated her professional life. That's probably my fault for reading this instead of a biography of her life.
Overall the book was probably about 20% too long. That said, I'm still glad to have read it and to have learned about Belle Decosta Greene. I like that the authors stuck to historical facts within the story. I feel like I got a sense of what her balancing act might have been like...both as a Black woman in a white world and as a person whose family had modest means surrounded by Morgans and other Gilded Age families.