You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
emilyreads15 's review for:
Guardians of Dawn: Zhara
by S. Jae-Jones
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Thank you so much to Netgalley and Wednesday Books for an E-ARC of this book in exchange for a honest review.
Guardians of Dawn: Zhara was a book that I was truly hoping to like. In fact I thought I would love it, since it sounded like a promising fantasy novel. However, it’s a book that continues to prove that a pretty cover doesn’t make a fascinating story.
To start off, this book was a decent idea of a fantasy novel and with proper execution it could’ve been amazing. But it just wasn’t. For one, I despised the writing. I’m aware that the author included a note at the beginning of the book, explaining why they wrote it the way they did. And while I’m happy they are proud of what they wrote I also need to say that it was confusing. As someone who is not very familiar with Asian culture, I was excited to learn more about it but this book made me feel so lost. I had no idea what it was talking about and was unfamiliar with much of the language. I didn’t want to have to look up a word every 5 minutes.
Another issue I found for this writing, also had to do with marketing. The marketing for this book was that it was YA sailor moon meets Cinder. For one, I know nothing about sailor moon so I didn’t see the appeal and still don’t which is just my own personal issue. But Cinder? I loved that book so much and other than the references to Asian culture and the so called cinderella retelling in both novels, they didn’t feel similar at all. Lastly this book is not YA. It’s been marketed at that genre but it’s not and I know many agree. YA or Young Adult is aimed for teenagers. Such an audience is able to read more mature content just without so much graphic detail that adult books have. Guardians of Dawn: Zhara was written way to immaturely to be for teens. I felt as though I was reading a middle grade book. Even Harry Potter felt more mature than this.
Such immaturity brings me to discuss the characters. The main protagonists were 17 years old but acted as though they were 10. The MMC, Han, was a typical jock dressed up to be a prince. He literally lacked common sense and only cares about his looks, as pointed out many times by the other characters. On top of that he was obsessed with romance novels but then proceeded to be afraid of girls. His whole personality was his waitlisting and his romance novels. As for the MFC, Zhara, she acted like a school girl who would make a fool or herself in front of her crush. I was hoping for a powerful female lead but she lacked it completely. Everyone walked all over her and she completely lacked any strength or power the entire book until suddenly in the last couple of chapters she knew exactly how to handle her magic and how to save the world. Even though she failed all her lessons the whole book.
On top of this the romance between Han and Zhara, it was predictable from the start, which is part of why I don’t like reading retellings much. I mean this retelling wasn’t even a good one. Her stepmother was just mid and she only had one stepsister that did actually love her. Anyways, her relationship with Han was like watching two 12 year olds be pushed together by their friends and then share an awkward kiss in front of everyone. Han didn’t know how to act around her at all. And Zhara has a weird habit of getting the “good-looking giggles” where she giggles around anyone she finds good looking. Like wth? 😐 On top of that we got a pov from both characters and Zhara acted completely different in both. When we saw her from Han’s perspective she was like all flirty and confident but when we got her own pov she was all fawn-like. Nothing really lined up or was consistent in this book.
I appreciated the author including lgbtq characters in this novel. In fact Xu, who identifies as they/them, as well as Yuli, who was a lesbian, were my two favorites characters. But none the less it was mentioned quite frequently in the novel how identifying that way was looked down upon in the morning realms. With Xu it felt a little forced on the character. But since I’m not apart of the community, I don’t feel comfortable addressing anything. You’ll have to ask someone who is more able to relate.
So at the end of the day, Yuli was the only well done character. She was the badass female lead that I wanted but didn’t get. I would have preferred that the book be written about her. She knew what she wanted and she knew how to get it. And unlike Zhara she understood magic and knew how to wield it.
The only other thing I liked was the elemental guardian’s companions. Such as the ginger cat named Sajah. I loved that cat so much. He was my favorite character. Which at first I didn’t even like his bc when her meowed the author would be like “‘purrrt’ said the ginger cat” I’m sorry what? Idk the writing of the whole book was off to me.
I literally gave the extra .5 star for Yuli and Sajah the naughty ginger cat.
I know I’ve already said a lot and at the beginning of this I did say it could’ve been a good book. It’s true it could’ve been but at the same time it was a basic plot. —> secret magical girl and some unfortunate prince run into eachother while seeking some all powerful elemental guardians. Said magic girl also happens to have a magic animal sidekick and poor prince can’t do anything for himself so he has to bring his smarter, wiser best friend with him. Alas they find said guardians and help save the day. And somehow their parents don’t care at all what they are doing. Don’t even suspect a damn thing. If any of you have ever seen the movie: Guardians of Ga’Hoole (yk the one with the owls) then just know this book is the same plot but with humans and Cinderella romance.
Okay I’ve said enough now. I’m really proud if anyone made it to the end of this crazy review. Deep down, I think this book is definitely for someone. And I think children between the ages of 11-13 would eat this up. But unfortunately it’s not for me. I’m truly shocked I read it to the end bc I wanted to DNF on chapter 3.
Read this book if you want some elemental magic and a slight Cinderella retelling. (Assuming your even still interested after reading this entire review.)
One again thanks to Netgalley and Wednesday Books for this E-ARC. I really appreciate the opportunity but just wasn’t for me.
Guardians of Dawn: Zhara was a book that I was truly hoping to like. In fact I thought I would love it, since it sounded like a promising fantasy novel. However, it’s a book that continues to prove that a pretty cover doesn’t make a fascinating story.
To start off, this book was a decent idea of a fantasy novel and with proper execution it could’ve been amazing. But it just wasn’t. For one, I despised the writing. I’m aware that the author included a note at the beginning of the book, explaining why they wrote it the way they did. And while I’m happy they are proud of what they wrote I also need to say that it was confusing. As someone who is not very familiar with Asian culture, I was excited to learn more about it but this book made me feel so lost. I had no idea what it was talking about and was unfamiliar with much of the language. I didn’t want to have to look up a word every 5 minutes.
Another issue I found for this writing, also had to do with marketing. The marketing for this book was that it was YA sailor moon meets Cinder. For one, I know nothing about sailor moon so I didn’t see the appeal and still don’t which is just my own personal issue. But Cinder? I loved that book so much and other than the references to Asian culture and the so called cinderella retelling in both novels, they didn’t feel similar at all. Lastly this book is not YA. It’s been marketed at that genre but it’s not and I know many agree. YA or Young Adult is aimed for teenagers. Such an audience is able to read more mature content just without so much graphic detail that adult books have. Guardians of Dawn: Zhara was written way to immaturely to be for teens. I felt as though I was reading a middle grade book. Even Harry Potter felt more mature than this.
Such immaturity brings me to discuss the characters. The main protagonists were 17 years old but acted as though they were 10. The MMC, Han, was a typical jock dressed up to be a prince. He literally lacked common sense and only cares about his looks, as pointed out many times by the other characters. On top of that he was obsessed with romance novels but then proceeded to be afraid of girls. His whole personality was his waitlisting and his romance novels. As for the MFC, Zhara, she acted like a school girl who would make a fool or herself in front of her crush. I was hoping for a powerful female lead but she lacked it completely. Everyone walked all over her and she completely lacked any strength or power the entire book until suddenly in the last couple of chapters she knew exactly how to handle her magic and how to save the world. Even though she failed all her lessons the whole book.
On top of this the romance between Han and Zhara, it was predictable from the start, which is part of why I don’t like reading retellings much. I mean this retelling wasn’t even a good one. Her stepmother was just mid and she only had one stepsister that did actually love her. Anyways, her relationship with Han was like watching two 12 year olds be pushed together by their friends and then share an awkward kiss in front of everyone. Han didn’t know how to act around her at all. And Zhara has a weird habit of getting the “good-looking giggles” where she giggles around anyone she finds good looking. Like wth? 😐 On top of that we got a pov from both characters and Zhara acted completely different in both. When we saw her from Han’s perspective she was like all flirty and confident but when we got her own pov she was all fawn-like. Nothing really lined up or was consistent in this book.
I appreciated the author including lgbtq characters in this novel. In fact Xu, who identifies as they/them, as well as Yuli, who was a lesbian, were my two favorites characters. But none the less it was mentioned quite frequently in the novel how identifying that way was looked down upon in the morning realms. With Xu it felt a little forced on the character. But since I’m not apart of the community, I don’t feel comfortable addressing anything. You’ll have to ask someone who is more able to relate.
So at the end of the day, Yuli was the only well done character. She was the badass female lead that I wanted but didn’t get. I would have preferred that the book be written about her. She knew what she wanted and she knew how to get it. And unlike Zhara she understood magic and knew how to wield it.
The only other thing I liked was the elemental guardian’s companions. Such as the ginger cat named Sajah. I loved that cat so much. He was my favorite character. Which at first I didn’t even like his bc when her meowed the author would be like “‘purrrt’ said the ginger cat” I’m sorry what? Idk the writing of the whole book was off to me.
I literally gave the extra .5 star for Yuli and Sajah the naughty ginger cat.
I know I’ve already said a lot and at the beginning of this I did say it could’ve been a good book. It’s true it could’ve been but at the same time it was a basic plot. —> secret magical girl and some unfortunate prince run into eachother while seeking some all powerful elemental guardians. Said magic girl also happens to have a magic animal sidekick and poor prince can’t do anything for himself so he has to bring his smarter, wiser best friend with him. Alas they find said guardians and help save the day. And somehow their parents don’t care at all what they are doing. Don’t even suspect a damn thing. If any of you have ever seen the movie: Guardians of Ga’Hoole (yk the one with the owls) then just know this book is the same plot but with humans and Cinderella romance.
Okay I’ve said enough now. I’m really proud if anyone made it to the end of this crazy review. Deep down, I think this book is definitely for someone. And I think children between the ages of 11-13 would eat this up. But unfortunately it’s not for me. I’m truly shocked I read it to the end bc I wanted to DNF on chapter 3.
Read this book if you want some elemental magic and a slight Cinderella retelling. (Assuming your even still interested after reading this entire review.)
One again thanks to Netgalley and Wednesday Books for this E-ARC. I really appreciate the opportunity but just wasn’t for me.