Let me start off by saying, no one writes an unlikable character quite like Eliza clark.

Penance tells us the fictional “non fiction” tale of Joan Wilson’s death and all those who played a part in it. We learn the small sea side towns history and lore and see how that fuels the girl’s imaginations. We are taken on a twisted and compelling journey through the young girls lives as seen in real life and their blogs. We learn the toxicity and cruelty of teenage girls with social media accounts. We examine the class and hierarchy of the small town, how someone always knows someone that can take care of it for you. No one ever has to suffer consequences why should they?

This book is unlike anything I’ve ever read. I found myself entranced by the narrative and how tumblr posts and subcultures were painted. I was there throughout the tumblr true crime era. I know the chaos and cringe of which this book speaks. Pushing the social boundaries of not only being a teenager but also being a girl. I think penance does all of this and then some. It flips the true crime genre on its head in such a fun and exciting way. Just when you think you know what happens next, you don’t. Much like boy parts, Eliza clark knows how to wow you!

Thank you netgalley and Harper books for the eARC!