I have seen the movie several times and this is the second time reading the short story. I only read this story in the book titled Close Range, Wyoming Stories. Simple, no frills, country boy talking, not much conversation story. I am biased because in my head, I constantly compared it to the awesome movie. This book portrays both guys as not attractive, Jack seemed to be eyeing Ennis from the beginning, and Ennis is disgusting and refused to be more successful despite opportunities. Jack is manipulative, his wife is straight cold hearted and Alma got the short end of the stick from the beginning. The scene in front of the campfire where Ennis is hugging Jack from behind is really beautiful/emotional. It is the most memorable part of the book and film. Decent story, but the film really brought this story to life and will forever remain in my heart.