You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

rkmoriyama 's review for:

A Rival Most Vial by R.K. Ashwick
4.0

* I received an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review. * 

If you love low stake fantasy where the characters' relationships are at the forefront, this novel is for you! 

Wow, okay, I don’t know how to start. 

“A Rival Most Vial” is a treasure of a novel. The low stakes and cozy atmosphere make the reading experience quite joyful and relaxing. It’s a quick read too! Surely made for a one-sitting-read on a rainy day. 

What I really enjoyed about this novel (other than the story) is how much representation, and good representation at that, that the novel contains. And I’m not talking solely about the LGBT representation, which is lovely I might add, but also about the absolutely heartwarming found family trope that is very prevalent in the novel. I loved how, despite their differences, the shopkeepers on Rosemond Street have become a family that cares for each other. 

But it is how well the author brings forth the everyday struggles that I really enjoy seeing in a novel. It is Ambrose’s loneliness, Dawn’s need to continuously prove herself worthy through commissions and committees, and Eli’s struggle to find what it is he is meant to do in life and how very supportive his family and friends are of his various attempts at finding this that made me feel all warm in my heart. 

I gave “A Rival Most Vial” a high 4-star rating and that is only because I personally wanted to see a little more on the worldbuilding side. 

I know not all readers will be bothered by this, but as a worldbuilding enthusiast, I am lacking some understanding of the fantasy races in this story. While it doesn’t have a huge impact on the story, I personally feel that if orcs and gnomes are named as such, I’d like for at least a little understanding of how, in this novel, orcs differ from other stories. It only bothered me at the beginning though. 

Also, the Scar is such an interesting setting, but I did struggle to properly get a mental image of where locations were in relation to each other. It was four levels up and three levels down (I don’t think three levels down is a thing in the novel, but it illustrates my dilemma) and I felt a little lost in the end. 

I am very glad I got a chance to read “A Rival Most Vial” and I must say, Ambrose Beake just waltzed right into my heart and made a home there. This sweet man tugged at my heartstrings all throughout this novel and will probably live there for quite some time. R.K. Ashwick made a splendid job making these characters feel alive and tangible, even those with smaller roles. 

I am looking forward to what else R.K. Ashwick might come up with in the future and I’ll be sure to grab myself a physical copy of “A Vial Most Rival” come March.