mathildur's profile picture

mathildur 's review for:

Blue Lily, Lily Blue by Maggie Stiefvater
5.0

Third time reading:
Love, love, love! I feel like this is very much Adam's book in the series, and I finally love him enough to enjoy watching him grow into his new role. Adam is the kind of character who grows on me for every reread I do! The first time around I disliked him so much, now I love him completely.

Second time reading:
I think I have to up this rating from 4,5 stars to 5 stars. I think at first there was simply too much happening in this book for me to be able to properly pay attention to it all. But this time around, seeing as it was a reread, it was easier! Every single character in this book was enjoyable to read about, even the adults and yes, even the "bad guys". I'm just in love with how Stiefvater writes dialogue, interactions and relations! If I had to pick one "least favourite" of the books, this might still be it, but there's no denying it's a well-written amazing YA book! I'm so glad I reread it.

First time reading:
Rating: 4.5 stars.

I am in awe at this series, but I have to admit I just didn't love this one as much as the previous book. Maybe I'll understand it better once I re-read it at some point. Now, onto the next one!