awesomeeallyson's profile picture

awesomeeallyson 's review for:

Catherine House by Elisabeth Thomas
2.0
dark sad slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: N/A
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

I read this book after seeing some meh reviews, and somehow I was still disappointed by it. This is going to be a brutally honest review. Get ready. But first, I did really enjoy Elisabeth Thomas' writing. The way she described the Catherine House was incredibly thoughtful and intentional. Thomas is an talented writer in a technical sense. Catherine House gave off "The Secret History" vibes, but if the characters were flatter and there was no plot.  Where this book fell apart is in the characters and plot line. I want to say this is a very heavy character driven story...but the characters don't really reflect on themselves, grow or change. They're all one-dimensional. You can see how they look and their actions but you don't really see anything deeper than that. I think if this story were a short story it would have done much better. Thomas had a great initial idea, but rather then fleshing out the story line or characters she filled the book with beautiful descriptions.

I found Ines to be really unlikeable, which isn't a bad thing if there's a reason behind it, but in this case I couldn't find one. She's curt, dispassionate and downright rude in most cases. She's got this traumatic past that is supposed to haunt her, but you don't really see that. She's impassive and just kind of exists without any emotion. 

I also had trouble getting invested in the storyline. There's supposed to be this big tragedy, but it happens then gets forgotten until it's convenient to mention again. It's supposed to effect the rest of the book but I think it could have not happened and the book would have progressed in the same way. The ending was strong and I actually started to get into by the last chapter...unfortunately by then I was just happy to see it ending so I could pick up my next book.

I do want to end this on a good note: I think Elisabeth Thomas could be a great writer. The potential is there and for that reason I could totally see myself reading another book by her and I'm definitely going to read her essays.