readingbykara's profile picture

readingbykara 's review for:

Split or Swallow by Lindsay Straube
2.0
adventurous dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I don’t quite know where to start with this. I am having some mixed feelings so bear with me.

The overall concept was intriguing. The book is unlike anything I have read before. You have basilisk’s teaching young women how to give pleasure so that the prince may find a wife. It had a lot of potential to have a very interesting plot, and at points it delivers on that potential. However, at the same time, I felt like it missed the mark on other things.

1. This books was too long. On my kindle, it was about 750 pages. There were many moments where the story dragged and sagged because the author relied on sex to carry the weight of the plot. If you’re going to make a book that long, I as a reader tend to expect a bit more emphasis on the plot. 

2. The sex … why was there so much??? Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy some smut as much as the next gal. However, there is such a thing as too much smut, especially when the book is as long as it is. I felt like the plot of the book suffered from this. I was given very little reasons to care about really anybody in this book. I didn’t really care for the humans; I didn’t even really care for the basilisks. The motivating factors of the villains is power and revenge, which I understand to a degree, but outside of a couple of side conversations, you’re really not given the opportunity to form a complete opinion one way or another.

3. Because of the huge emphasis on smut throughout this whole book, I feel as though the characters never had the chance to shine and showcase who they were outside the context of sex. I was never given a chance to grow any fondness for the two love interests and the main character. I didn’t fully know who they were, what their motivations were, or really anything else about them outside of sex because all their interactions involved sex in someway, shape, or form. 

4. The author does not provide a trigger warning list, or at least a “read at your own risk” blurb within the book itself. I personally did not appreciate it. I would have much preferred a heads up about the multiple references to SA, and dubious consent that seems to be absolutely throughout this book. I believe there are ways to provide a trigger warning list that doesn’t necessarily spoil a book, but at least inform the readers to set their expectations appropriately. I do not feel as though the author accurately prepared me for what I was about to read. That said, I do not yuck anybody’s yum. Read what you want, but I am fully of the belief that readers should be allowed to make informed decisions about the books they pick up. 

This all said, I wanted to like it. It really is unlike anything else I have ever read. If you really are not a stickler about plot, and really are only interested in the smut, then this is that book. For me, it didn’t hit the mark, and I’m okay with that. If there’s ever a book 2, I don’t think I’ll pick it up personally. This book will definitely satisfy someone, that someone is just not me.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings