I loved this book it was a great bit of more story to this already really well fleshed world. I loved the characters so much but I especially loved An Ning and Karana they fit so well together these two have loved on another for many of An Ning's lives many of which Karana feels like he has failed her and how what he is does that curses all whom he has ever loved. I loved the plot it started as a slowing moving story of An Ning remembering lives and the many tragic ways she has died with Karana never being able to stop a single one for which he feels cursed the story moves to telling me about Karana and how this all started I really loved the ending though a great end to an amazing story.