You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao
4.0
adventurous dark informative tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

tdlr/summary: 
Well paced story with an interesting premise and very investing execution and likeable characters that however tries to tackle more topics than it can reasonably explore. 
The problems in my opinion are mostly(!) minor and only come to your attention when you actively try to think about something to criticize.

Long version:
Now I have to say, while I had a lot of fun with the novel, it is difficult to put into words which exact parts of it I liked in greater detail. A great deal of my enjoyment probably comes from Xiran's writing style, their descriptions of characters, events and things as a whole. 
So while the criticism part of this review will probably be longer, bear in mind that it didn't really affect my enjoyment of the entire thing. 

One thing that specifically jumped at my attention is the pleasant pacing. The story keeps moving forward and doesn't linger on one event for too long or spends a lot of time with unnecessary scenes. For example the characters' training montage only gets mentioned in fleeting sentences between events and dialog that actually matter. 

Another thing I found great joy in is the three protagonists and the way they speak and act with each other and other side characters. It was a bit weird to me how colloquially high royal strategists like Sima Yi spoke, however it probably adds to their relatability, which is very high for a novel about billionaires, ancient military strategists, war criminals and more. 

Another noteworthy part of the experience are the fight scenes in which the characters mount giant battle robots. It is said that fights in this setup rarely take more than an hour before they are over, which again adds to the pleasant pacing. Another thing that helps these battles to be a fun highlight every time they occur is that each of them is different and serves a different purpose in the narrative. In contrasts, fights that don't do such a thing don't happen or are skimmed over with a statement like "But nothing interesting happened. I was surprised how easy it was/nothing went wrong for once." 

However, the story tries to tackle a lot of topics: racism, sexism and mysoginy, capitalism, love - while there's no direct homophobia, it does criticize society's obsession with monogamy/opposition to polyamory - there's even a paragraph or two about gender identity.
All these things together lead to the problem that each discussion of them is quite shallow and not explored to an extend that it should.

Especially the racist attacks feel kind of odd because Xiran themself has criticised works before in which racism is reduced to insulting ethnic minorities with verbal slurs. However that's more or less the only form of racism the two relevant rongdi characters face. That combined with the fact that both of them already have reasons why society hates them outside of their ethnicity has the consequence that the racism subplot can be dropped without consequences for the narrative.
And that is before you consider that protagonist Zetian thinks racism is stupid the second she explains to the reader that it is a thing in this world. It has no narrative benefit for any character.
(Edit: It was brought to my attention that Qieluo was aggressive and outgoing because of the racist sentiments toward her and not the other way around.)

This last thing bothered me especially, but it is connected to spoilers. So to avoid those, feel free to quit reading from here on.

A large portion of Xiran's PR for this novel revolves around the fact that the three protagonists end up in a polyamorous relationship where each character has a crush on each of the others.
However within the novel itself, the part of the story where this is the case is very short. It is probably around 3 or 4 chapters and within the story it's less than 48 hours. That is because Li Shimin effectively dies the next battle. We see exactly one scene in which the three of them act as a polyamorous couple together.
That is effectively the bury your gays trope and it left a very sour taste in me that this part is such an important thing in the marketing but so Minor in the novel.

Now I say "effectively" because in the epilogue we find out that a mysterious group of people - presumably the so called Gods of their world - rescued the remains of Shimin's corpse and keep him alive to blackmail Zetian into obedience. The sequel probably has a good portion of the plot be getting Shimin back from those people. This still means that the characters are separated and can't act as a couple. The sequel has potential to remedy this part of my critique, but I'm still skeptical.