You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo
by Taylor Jenkins Reid
adventurous
dark
emotional
informative
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
tldr/summary:
I really want to give this book 5 stars because I love it a lot, but I think there's just a tad too many tiny things bothering me for that. Mostly Monique's story, both on its own and how it ties in with Evelyn's.
But overall, I really adore the story that is told by Evelyn of what she experienced in her life. There's a very unique tension from the way it's told and the context it is given. All the characters are amazing, lovable or not. While the central romance of the story is great in most of its many facets, it did fall just a tiny bit flat for me.
Long version:
The story of Evelyn Hugo is framed as real events that happened within her universe that she now recounts years later to a reporter. This is a very interesting way of describing the entire thing. Before Monique goes to interview Evelyn, she does some research about her.
That way we learn a few key details about Evelyn's life long before they happen from a reader's perspective. However we are lacking almost all context for these events.
This creates some interesting dynamics where you have the realization: "Ah, she's gonna marry this guy some day in the future. Let's see how that plays out."
One husband especially is very interesting in that regard because of what we learn about him very early on. And then later when it makes sense why they married, you start wondering why they'd ever break up again.
The husbands in general are quite interestingly handled. Creating 7 marriage plots within the framework of one story and one character is a lot. Yet they are very elegantly handled. Not all of them are handled with equal attention - a good chunk of husbands aren't actually characterized for more than a very brief amount of pages - but the reasons of why Evelyn marries them and how their lives play out after the marriage is always unique and different (except for maybe one shortly mentioned guy).
However within Evelyn's life, one love interest is the most important one, the central focus of the novel. While I liked that character and their dynamic with Evelyn, their romance did fall a bit flat for me. That is mainly due to how we skip over almost all their happy time together. When there is a ten year time frame in which they just live a happy life, we essentially just skip to the next time there's tension and drama between them. This makes it a bit hard to believe that this is the true love story of Evelyn's life when we only ever see the bad times of it.
Another thing that didn't land with me was Monique's story. She's the reporter who Evelyn tells her life story to and she has her own story and character arc. It is given less attention than Evelyn's, between the beginning and ending chapters, she gets to live her own life only every now and then.
The problems I have with her chapters are several. First of all, I feel like the writing style is much less elegantly executed when things happen from Monique's perspective. Usually she is either with Evelyn or alone. This means her chapters are either there to spell out the subtext of Evelyn's chapters directly or she has to tell us her life story and emotions without any real reason to do so.
She usually laments a lot about her own emotions and thoughts very unsubtly and spends way too much time not actually doing anything.
Another thing about Monique is that Evelyn has a specific reason as to why she tells her story to her and not any other reporter. At various points, there's very unsubtle foreshadowing to a big reveal at the end - Evelyn outright says "You specifically will hate me when I'm done telling my story." at least twice.
The thing is: I don't really care about that reveal. The reader isn't given enough to emotionally connect to the event or the involved characters.
And aside from that, Monique's reaction to that reveal is also very unreasonable. I just don't think, given all the individual information and circumstances, that she has any substantial reason to be so mad at Evelyn. Especially not for several months.
I really did not connect with Monique on any level, so I'm glad the Evelyn-Monique-Attention-Split is not 50/50 but more around 70/30, putting most of the attention on the better characters and storyllines.
I really want to give this book 5 stars because I love it a lot, but I think there's just a tad too many tiny things bothering me for that. Mostly Monique's story, both on its own and how it ties in with Evelyn's.
But overall, I really adore the story that is told by Evelyn of what she experienced in her life. There's a very unique tension from the way it's told and the context it is given. All the characters are amazing, lovable or not. While the central romance of the story is great in most of its many facets, it did fall just a tiny bit flat for me.
Long version:
The story of Evelyn Hugo is framed as real events that happened within her universe that she now recounts years later to a reporter. This is a very interesting way of describing the entire thing. Before Monique goes to interview Evelyn, she does some research about her.
That way we learn a few key details about Evelyn's life long before they happen from a reader's perspective. However we are lacking almost all context for these events.
This creates some interesting dynamics where you have the realization: "Ah, she's gonna marry this guy some day in the future. Let's see how that plays out."
One husband especially is very interesting in that regard because of what we learn about him very early on. And then later when it makes sense why they married, you start wondering why they'd ever break up again.
The husbands in general are quite interestingly handled. Creating 7 marriage plots within the framework of one story and one character is a lot. Yet they are very elegantly handled. Not all of them are handled with equal attention - a good chunk of husbands aren't actually characterized for more than a very brief amount of pages - but the reasons of why Evelyn marries them and how their lives play out after the marriage is always unique and different (except for maybe one shortly mentioned guy).
However within Evelyn's life, one love interest is the most important one, the central focus of the novel. While I liked that character and their dynamic with Evelyn, their romance did fall a bit flat for me. That is mainly due to how we skip over almost all their happy time together. When there is a ten year time frame in which they just live a happy life, we essentially just skip to the next time there's tension and drama between them. This makes it a bit hard to believe that this is the true love story of Evelyn's life when we only ever see the bad times of it.
Another thing that didn't land with me was Monique's story. She's the reporter who Evelyn tells her life story to and she has her own story and character arc. It is given less attention than Evelyn's, between the beginning and ending chapters, she gets to live her own life only every now and then.
The problems I have with her chapters are several. First of all, I feel like the writing style is much less elegantly executed when things happen from Monique's perspective. Usually she is either with Evelyn or alone. This means her chapters are either there to spell out the subtext of Evelyn's chapters directly or she has to tell us her life story and emotions without any real reason to do so.
She usually laments a lot about her own emotions and thoughts very unsubtly and spends way too much time not actually doing anything.
Another thing about Monique is that Evelyn has a specific reason as to why she tells her story to her and not any other reporter. At various points, there's very unsubtle foreshadowing to a big reveal at the end - Evelyn outright says "You specifically will hate me when I'm done telling my story." at least twice.
The thing is: I don't really care about that reveal. The reader isn't given enough to emotionally connect to the event or the involved characters.
And aside from that, Monique's reaction to that reveal is also very unreasonable. I just don't think, given all the individual information and circumstances, that she has any substantial reason to be so mad at Evelyn. Especially not for several months.
I really did not connect with Monique on any level, so I'm glad the Evelyn-Monique-Attention-Split is not 50/50 but more around 70/30, putting most of the attention on the better characters and storyllines.