illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

Water Shall Refuse Them by Lucie McKnight Hardy
4.0
dark mysterious medium-paced

In the heatwave of 1976, a grieving family move to a dilapidated cottage in rural Wales hoping a change of scene will ease their pain. With the villagers proving unwelcoming and her family unravelling around her, 16-year-old Nif finds comfort in an invented religion she calls the Creed. Then she meets her neighbour Mally, who has his own and secrets to share. 

This is a dark, languid book where the threat of violence glowers on the horizon. Everything feels stickily oppressive - the endless heat, the inescapable dust, the hostile glares of the villagers and the thinly-veiled tension between Nif's parents.

Nif is a fascinating but unnerving narrator, capable of incredible harshness and cruelty. She's detached in the face of her mother's breakdown and her father's attempts at keeping on, observing family dynamics with clinical coldness, yet she's caring and affectionate towards her younger brother Lorry. With the help of the Creed she believes she can remember the end of the dream of her sister's death that's haunting her and stop more bad things happening. Her odd, obsessive rituals and relic collecting show a mind scrambling to make sense of terrible loss, filling in the blanks so as not to look too closely. 

I loved the weirdness of the isolated rural setting; there are strange customs and webs of resentment that the newcomers blunder into, and there's even a scene where the family walk into the pub to be greeted by silence and stares from the locals. Between this, the powerfully uncomfortable family dynamics, and Nif and Mally's increasingly occult activities, a folk-horror dread shimmers like heat haze throughout the book.

There are parts where the pacing falters, but when the folk-horror and coming of age elements meet the effect is dark, surprising, and disquieting. I'd say this is less straight-forwardly 'witchy' than the blurb might make it seem, though the trappings are certainly there. Instead it's girlhood at its most feral, with McKnight Hardy unafraid to explore everything cruel and rotten a grief-mangled psyche might be capable of.